Please wait..
Please wait..
30 Dec 2024 Blogs
The Best Key Lime Pie Spots in the Florida Keys: A Sweet Escape to Paradise
If you're planning a trip to the Florida Keys, there’s one iconic dessert that should be on your must-try list—Key Lime Pie. This tart, sweet, and perfectly creamy treat is a Florida Keys staple, and no visit is complete without sampling a slice or two. But where should you go for the best Key Lime Pie? From the northernmost point of Key Largo to the southernmost tip of Key West, we've compiled a list of the best places to enjoy this beloved dessert in the Keys.
A true Key West institution, Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe is often considered one of the best places for Key Lime Pie in the entire Keys. Located in the heart of Old Town, this family-owned shop has been serving up delicious, tart pies for over 20 years. Kermit's is famous for its classic pie as well as its Key Lime Pie on a stick, dipped in chocolate. Whether you prefer your pie traditional or with a fun twist, Kermit's will not disappoint.
For a slice of pie that locals rave about, head to the Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory in Tavernier, located in the middle of the Keys. The Blond Giraffe has earned a loyal following for its smooth, creamy filling and perfectly balanced tartness. Their pies are made from fresh, local Key limes and baked daily, ensuring a fresh experience with every bite. If you're not in the mood for a whole pie, you can grab a slice or even indulge in a Key Lime Pie milkshake for a sweet, refreshing treat.
Islamorada, known as the "Village of Islands," offers a picturesque backdrop to indulge in one of the best slices of Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys. The Key Lime Pie Ladys is a must for pie enthusiasts. While she doesnt have a stand alone location yet, this special pie is served at many iconic places in the Keys - Including the Trading Post in Islamorada. Served in a traditional graham cracker crust and topped with a perfect layer of whipped cream, it’s the kind of dessert that’s worth a stop on its own.
Located in the northernmost Key, Key Largo, Mrs. Mac's Kitchen has been serving up classic, homemade comfort food for decades, and their Key Lime Pie is no exception. Known for its generous portions and friendly service, Mrs. Mac's offers a Key Lime Pie that strikes the perfect balance between tangy and sweet. The pie is light, airy, and wonderfully refreshing, making it the ideal end to a meal. Plus, the laid-back, homey vibe of the restaurant adds to the charm of this dining experience.
If you find yourself in Key West and want a slightly more modern take on the traditional Key Lime Pie, The Floridian is a great option. Known for its creative, locally-inspired cuisine, The Floridian’s Key Lime Pie features a twist: it’s served in a mason jar! The smooth filling and tangy lime flavor are still front and center, but the mason jar presentation adds a fun, quirky touch that’s uniquely Key West. It’s a great spot for those who want a bit of local flair with their dessert.
For another delicious Key Lime Pie experience in Key West, look no further than the Key West Key Lime Pie Co. This quaint shop has earned its reputation by serving up some of the best pies in the region, and they offer an extensive selection of treats, from whole pies to pie-flavored fudge and key lime pie cookies. Their traditional Key Lime Pie is rich, creamy, and perfectly sweetened, and it’s a must-try for any pie lover.
The Tasting Room in Key West offers an upscale twist on the classic Key Lime Pie. While this isn’t a pie shop per se, it’s a perfect stop for those looking for an elegant Key Lime Pie experience paired with some of the Keys’ best wines. The pie here is served as a mini, individual portion, allowing for an elegant, refined presentation. The subtle lime flavor, smooth filling, and buttery crust make this pie a perfect choice for dessert after a leisurely meal.
Located in Marathon, Sunset Grille & Raw Bar is known for its casual, relaxed atmosphere and stunning waterfront views. But it's their Key Lime Pie that has visitors raving. The pie is served in a perfect graham cracker crust, and its filling is a blend of creamy texture and tartness that hits all the right notes. What sets this place apart is the location—dining here with a slice of Key Lime Pie while watching the sun set over the water is an experience you won’t forget.
Another gem in Marathon, The Pie Factory is a great stop for pie lovers in the middle Keys. Their Key Lime Pie is everything you could want—smooth, tart, and balanced perfectly with sweetness. The Pie Factory also offers several other pie varieties, so if you’re traveling with friends who prefer other flavors, everyone can find something they’ll love. The small-town charm and focus on quality make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
The Florida Keys is a paradise for lovers of Key Lime Pie. Whether you’re looking for a classic slice or something a little more innovative, these pie spots are guaranteed to offer the perfect mix of tangy limes and sweet creaminess. Each place has its own unique spin on this beloved dessert, making it worth visiting multiple spots to compare and contrast the flavors. As you journey through the Keys, make sure to enjoy this local treat, and you’ll quickly discover why Key Lime Pie is so much more than just a dessert—it’s an essential part of the Florida Keys experience!
